Lesson 4 · 50 minutes · Grades 9–12
Negative equity is not the same as bankruptcy: what buybacks do to a balance sheet
Negative equity is not the same as bankruptcy is a free 50-minute high school lesson on what shareholders' equity measures. Students trace how buybacks pushed equity below zero at McDonald's, Starbucks and Lowe's, and how Home Depot's turned positive after its buybacks paused.
By Hardik Bhandare · Checked against filings: . Editorial policy. Corrections
- Grade
- High school, grades 9–12
- Time
- 50 minutes (splits into two 25-minute blocks)
- Formats
- Web page, student page, teacher guide (PDF), worksheet with exit ticket (PDF), answer key (PDF), slides (PowerPoint)
- Companies
- McDonald's, Starbucks, Lowe's, Home Depot
- Data
- Data from McDonald's FY2025 Form 10-K, filed Feb 24, 2026; McDonald's Q2 FY2026 Form 10-Q, filed Aug 7, 2026; Starbucks's FY2026 earnings release (Form 8-K), filed Oct 29, 2026; Starbucks's FY2025 Form 10-K, filed Nov 14, 2025; Lowe's FY2025 Form 10-K, filed Mar 23, 2026; Lowe's Q2 FY2026 Form 10-Q, filed Aug 27, 2026; Home Depot's FY2025 Form 10-K, filed Mar 18, 2026; and Home Depot's Q2 FY2026 Form 10-Q, filed Aug 25, 2026. Checked Nov 15, 2026.
- Edition
- 2026–27 first edition, v1.0
- License
- Free under CC BY-NC 4.0. No student logins.
It includes slides, a worksheet with an exit ticket, an answer key and a teacher guide. Students never log in.
McDonald's had bought back $79.3 billion of its own shares by Dec 31, 2025, more than the $70.3 billion of profit it had kept over its history. Students use that one line to explain why its equity was below zero.
What's included?
- PDFTeacher guide (PDF)172 KB
- PDFStudent worksheet (PDF)104 KB
- PDFAnswer key (PDF)90 KB
- PPTXSlides (PowerPoint)55 KB
Student page (no login, no answers)
cityfort.co/teachers/debt-cash-and-staying-power/negative-equity/student
Short link for the board: cityfort.co/class/negative-equity
Share with a class or a colleague
https://cityfort.co/teachers/debt-cash-and-staying-power/negative-equity
What will students learn?
Students can explain shareholders' equity as assets minus liabilities, name two ways it can fall below zero, and use a filing to say which one applies at a company.
- Students learn that shareholders' equity is what is left when liabilities are subtracted from assets, and that profit kept raises it while dividends and buybacks lower it.
- They see in real filings that a company can report negative equity while it keeps operating, because it has paid out more to shareholders than the profit it kept.
How long does this lesson take?
50 minutes (splits into two 25-minute blocks)
| Minutes | Step | What happens |
|---|---|---|
| 0–7 | Warm-up | A made-up lemonade company has $1,000 of assets and $700 of liabilities. It borrows $800 to buy back owners' shares. What happens to the owners' stake on paper? (made-up numbers) |
| 7–15 | What equity is | Equity = assets − liabilities. What raises it (profit kept, new shares) and what lowers it (losses, dividends, buybacks). |
| 15–32 | Four companies | Pairs read McDonald's, Starbucks, Lowe's and Home Depot and find, in each card, the fact that explains the sign of its equity. |
| 32–40 | Two roads below zero | Losses or payouts: the class sorts the cards and checks which road each filing shows. |
| 40–46 | Discussion | What does negative equity say, and what does it not say? Describe, don't judge. |
| 46–50 | Exit ticket | Exit ticket (4 questions). |
What do students need?
- The slides (projected) or the printed worksheet.
- One worksheet per student. It prints in black and white on two pages.
- A calculator.
- No accounts, no logins and no internet access are required. The student page is optional.
Discussion questions
- McDonald's had negative equity and still covered its FY2025 interest about 7.8 times. What does negative equity measure, and what does it not measure?
- Lowe's equity first fell below zero in FY2021, the year it bought back $13 billion of its shares. What do its filings show it did with its buybacks in FY2025?
- Home Depot's equity went from below zero in January 2022 to positive in August 2026. What changed, according to its filings?
- Negative equity can also come from losses. What would you look for in a 10-K to tell which road a company took? (Describe it. Do not judge it.)
How do I adapt it for ELL and IEP students?
- English language learners
- ELL: a picture of a bucket (equity) with a tap filling it (profit kept) and two drains (dividends, buybacks), a word bank and sentence frames.
- IEP and 504 plans
- IEP: the Part C table with the sign column filled in; students copy the reason from each card.
- Advanced students
- Advanced: students explain why Starbucks's long-term deferred revenue from Nestlé is a liability but not debt, using the card.
- Extension
- Students look up two more companies with negative equity on Cityfort, for example Domino's or Yum Brands, and copy the page's note on why equity is below zero. They describe each in one sentence. Read Cityfort's Learn entry What are stock buybacks?
Which standards does it support?
We say a lesson supports a standard, never that it covers it fully.
- CCSS.ELA-Literacy.RH.11-12.7 (Common Core states): Integrate and evaluate multiple sources of information presented in diverse formats and media (e.g., visually, quantitatively, as well as in words) in order to address a question or solve a problem.
- CCSS.ELA-Literacy.RH.11-12.1 (Common Core states): Cite specific textual evidence to support analysis of primary and secondary sources, connecting insights gained from specific details to an understanding of the text as a whole.
- Investing 8-4 (Jump$tart / CEE National Standards), partly: Investors in corporate stock "become part-owners of a business" (shortened).
Teacher background in 2 minutes
Shareholders' equity
Equity is assets minus liabilities: what would be left for shareholders, on paper, if every debt and bill were paid. It is a bookkeeping total, not the market value of the shares.
What raises and lowers it
Profit kept in the business (retained earnings) and money from new shares raise equity. Losses, dividends and buybacks lower it.
Treasury stock
Some companies record bought-back shares as treasury stock, at what they paid, subtracted inside equity (McDonald's, Home Depot). Others retire the shares and take the cost from retained earnings (Starbucks, Lowe's). Either way, large buybacks over many years can exceed all the profit ever kept.
Two roads below zero
Equity can fall below zero through years of losses or through paying out more than the profit kept, often with borrowed money. The filing's equity section shows which.
Why it is not bankruptcy
Bankruptcy is a legal process when a company cannot pay what it owes. Negative equity is a balance-sheet total; a company can report it and keep paying its bills, as the four cards show.
Debt to equity
When equity is below zero, the debt-to-equity ratio has no meaning, so Cityfort pages leave it blank and say why.
If your class runs a stock-market simulation, these lessons can come before it: they explain what a company does and how it reports results. They do not suggest which companies to choose, and Cityfort does not run, rank or judge simulation picks.
What do the four company cards show?
Each card is copied from the company's Cityfort page, with the filing and date. Fiscal years differ: Lowe's and Home Depot end in late January or early February; Starbucks's ends in late September; McDonald's ends Dec 31.
- McDonald's: equity -$1.8 billion on Dec 31, 2025 and -$1,023 million on Jun 30, 2026. Treasury stock at cost $79.3 billion against retained earnings of $70.3 billion (Dec 31, 2025).
- Starbucks: equity -$7.7 billion on Sep 27, 2026, below zero in every year since at least FY2021. Buybacks $4 billion in FY2022; none in FY2025 or FY2026.
- Lowe's: equity -$9.9 billion on Jan 30, 2026 and -$7.4 billion on Jul 31, 2026. Buybacks of $32.1 billion in FY2020 to FY2022.
- Home Depot: equity -$1.7 billion on Jan 30, 2022 and $16.6 billion on Aug 2, 2026. Buybacks $14.8 billion in FY2021, then paused in March 2024.
Splitting into two 25-minute blocks
Teach minutes 0–25 in the first block, ending after two cards. Open the second block with a 3-minute recap of what raises and lowers equity, then the last two cards, the sort, discussion and the exit ticket.
How does the lesson support each standard?
This lesson supports the outcomes below. It does not cover all of any standard.
Common Core State Standards text: © Copyright 2010. National Governors Association Center for Best Practices and Council of Chief State School Officers. All rights reserved.
Standards text: National Standards for Personal Financial Education, Copyright © 2021, Council for Economic Education and Jump$tart Coalition for Personal Financial Literacy. All rights reserved. Reproduced for noncommercial educational purposes.
- Common Core RH.11-12.7: "Integrate and evaluate multiple sources of information presented in diverse formats and media…" Students combine balance-sheet totals across years with buyback figures from the cash flow statement to explain one number.
- Common Core RH.11-12.1: "Cite specific textual evidence to support analysis of primary and secondary sources…" Each explanation cites the fact and filing it rests on.
- National Standards for Personal Financial Education, Investing 8-4 (grade 8 standard, used as review): investors in corporate stock "become part-owners of a business" (shortened). Partial. Students learn what the owners' stake on a balance sheet records, and that it differs from what the shares trade for.
5-minute prep
- Print: the worksheet (one per student) and the answer key for yourself.
- Project: the slides. The company cards start on slide 5.
- Read: the "Teacher background in 2 minutes" box above and the discussion guidance in the teacher guide.
How were the figures worked out?
Every figure comes from Cityfort's published pages for McDonald's, Starbucks, Lowe's and Home Depot. Each page traces equity to the balance sheet and buybacks to the cash flow statement of the company's 10-K, 10-Q or earnings release. The only calculations are subtraction and totals, shown in the answer key.
Where does this lesson fit?
- Before: Lesson 3: Interest and maturities
- Next: Capstone: A debt and cash profile (optional)
- Unit: Debt, cash and staying power
- It builds on the lesson on dividends and buybacks in Who owns the company, and who controls it?, but works on its own.
- Learn (optional further reading, not needed for the lesson): What are stock buybacks? · What is debt to equity?
Where do the numbers come from?
Data from McDonald's FY2025 Form 10-K, filed Feb 24, 2026; McDonald's Q2 FY2026 Form 10-Q, filed Aug 7, 2026; Starbucks's FY2026 earnings release (Form 8-K), filed Oct 29, 2026; Starbucks's FY2025 Form 10-K, filed Nov 14, 2025; Lowe's FY2025 Form 10-K, filed Mar 23, 2026; Lowe's Q2 FY2026 Form 10-Q, filed Aug 27, 2026; Home Depot's FY2025 Form 10-K, filed Mar 18, 2026; and Home Depot's Q2 FY2026 Form 10-Q, filed Aug 25, 2026. Checked Nov 15, 2026. The lesson keeps these dated numbers until the next edition.
- S1 McDonald's: Form 10-K, fiscal year 2025 (ended Dec 31, 2025) · McDonald's Corporation (SEC EDGAR) · Feb 24, 2026
- S2 McDonald's: Form 10-Q, Q2 2026 (quarter ended Jun 30, 2026) · McDonald's Corporation (SEC EDGAR) · Aug 7, 2026
- S3 Starbucks: Q4 and fiscal 2026 earnings release (Form 8-K, Exhibit 99.1, Oct 29, 2026) · Starbucks Corporation (SEC EDGAR) · Oct 29, 2026
- S4 Starbucks: Form 10-K for fiscal year 2023 (ended Oct 1, 2023) · Starbucks Corporation (SEC EDGAR) · Nov 17, 2023
- S5 Starbucks: Form 10-K for fiscal year 2025 (ended Sep 28, 2025) · Starbucks Corporation (SEC EDGAR) · Nov 14, 2025
- S6 Lowe's: Form 10-K for fiscal 2025 (year ended Jan 30, 2026) · Lowe's Companies, Inc. (SEC EDGAR) · Mar 23, 2026
- S7 Lowe's: Form 10-K for fiscal 2022 (53 weeks, year ended Feb 3, 2023) · Lowe's Companies, Inc. (SEC EDGAR) · Mar 27, 2023
- S8 Lowe's: Form 10-Q for Q2 fiscal 2026 (quarter ended Jul 31, 2026) · Lowe's Companies, Inc. (SEC EDGAR) · Aug 27, 2026
- S9 Home Depot: Form 10-K for fiscal 2025 (year ended Feb 1, 2026) · The Home Depot, Inc. (SEC EDGAR) · Mar 18, 2026
- S10 Home Depot: Form 10-K for fiscal 2023 (year ended Jan 28, 2024) · The Home Depot, Inc. (SEC EDGAR) · Mar 13, 2024
- S11 Home Depot: Form 10-K for fiscal 2021 (year ended Jan 30, 2022) · The Home Depot, Inc. (SEC EDGAR) · Mar 23, 2022
- S12 Home Depot: Form 10-Q for Q2 fiscal 2026 (quarter ended Aug 2, 2026) · The Home Depot, Inc. (SEC EDGAR) · Aug 25, 2026
Questions teachers ask
- Is there a lesson on negative shareholders' equity for high school?
Cityfort's "Negative equity is not the same as bankruptcy" is a free 50-minute lesson. Students trace McDonald's, Starbucks, Lowe's and Home Depot from their filings to see how buybacks moved equity below zero, and back.
- Does negative equity mean a company is going bankrupt?
Negative equity is a balance-sheet total, and bankruptcy is a legal process when a company cannot pay its debts. All four companies in the lesson reported negative equity while they kept operating; the lesson describes each case and makes no forecast.
- Does the lesson judge the companies' buybacks?
The lesson never says whether a company's buybacks were right or wrong. Students describe what the filings show, and the answer key accepts no judging words.
- How old are the numbers?
Equity figures come from filings dated from March 2022 to October 2026, each with its balance-sheet date. Data checked Nov 15, 2026.
- Can I use it in Google Classroom, and do students need accounts?
Every file works in Google Classroom as a plain link, PDF or PowerPoint file, and students never create accounts.
- Is it free to copy and adapt?
Cityfort's lessons are licensed under CC BY-NC 4.0. You may copy and adapt them for noncommercial use if you credit Cityfort, link to the license and note any changes.
Optional further reading
These pages are on the main Cityfort site, which has its own ads and sign-up options. No lesson step needs them.
How do I credit and share it?
Credit line to copy: "Debt, cash and staying power: Lesson 4 – Negative equity is not the same as bankruptcy" by Cityfort (cityfort.co/teachers/debt-cash-and-staying-power/negative-equity), CC BY-NC 4.0. Data from McDonald's FY2025 Form 10-K, filed Feb 24, 2026; McDonald's Q2 FY2026 Form 10-Q, filed Aug 7, 2026; Starbucks's FY2026 earnings release (Form 8-K), filed Oct 29, 2026; Starbucks's FY2025 Form 10-K, filed Nov 14, 2025; Lowe's FY2025 Form 10-K, filed Mar 23, 2026; Lowe's Q2 FY2026 Form 10-Q, filed Aug 27, 2026; Home Depot's FY2025 Form 10-K, filed Mar 18, 2026; and Home Depot's Q2 FY2026 Form 10-Q, filed Aug 25, 2026.
License: CC BY-NC 4.0. If you change this material, please remove the Cityfort name or mark it as modified; changed versions are not reviewed by Cityfort.
Company names are trademarks of their owners; Cityfort is not affiliated with or endorsed by them.
Questions or corrections: contact us.
What changed (1)
- v1.0, Nov 15, 2026: First edition.
Last updated Nov 15, 2026.
Disclaimer
For learning only. Cityfort is not a registered investment adviser or broker-dealer and does not recommend buying or selling any security. Prices shown are dated and may be out of date.
Investing in securities involves risk, including loss of capital. Before making any investment decision, do your own research and consider consulting a registered investment adviser or other qualified professional.
Cityfort, its owners and contributors may or may not hold securities of companies covered. Cityfort is not paid by any company it covers. Content is not an offer or solicitation to buy or sell any security, including in any initial public offering.
Read the positions policyRead the full disclaimerHide the full disclaimer
Cityfort publishes general educational content that explains how listed companies work. Cityfort is not registered with the US Securities and Exchange Commission or any state securities regulator as an investment adviser, and is not a broker-dealer or a member of FINRA. Cityfort does not provide investment, tax or legal advice, recommendations, ratings, price targets or any opinion on whether to buy, sell or hold any security. Nothing on the site is tailored to any person's circumstances.
All information is taken from publicly available sources, mainly company filings with the SEC, which are listed on each page with dates. We work to keep it accurate and correct errors publicly, but we do not guarantee that it is complete, accurate or up to date. Any market price or price-based ratio shown is dated, may be out of date by the time you read it, and is included only to explain concepts.
Statements by company management, including forward-looking statements and guidance, are reported as the company's statements, with their date and source; they are not our forecasts. Adjusted (non-GAAP) figures are the company's own measures and are shown next to the official (GAAP) figures.