Compare · Industrials
American Airlines vs. United: how they make money
The same facts for both companies, in the same order, from each company's own page and filings. It is not a ranking.
How they differ
In FY2025, United's revenue of $59.1B was about 1.1 times American Airlines' $54.6B (Cityfort calculation: one divided by the other).
American Airlines reports one segment, American Airlines (one reported segment) (FY2025).
Domestic (share of passenger revenue) brought in 70.9% of American Airlines' revenue in FY2025; Domestic (U.S. and Canada) brought in 59.3% of United's revenue in FY2025.
American Airlines' largest payer group is Travelers buying tickets, 83.5% of revenue (FY2025); United's largest payer group is Travelers, 90.5% of revenue (FY2025).
American Airlines' page lists United among its competitors; United's page does not list American Airlines.
Each company in 5 points
American Airlines
1 · What it sells
American Airlines Group sells airline seats on 1,580 aircraft, plus AAdvantage miles and cargo space, with FY2025 revenue of $54.6 billion.
Sources and detail on the American Airlines page2 · Who pays it
In FY2025, ticket sales were 83.5% of revenue, miles redeemed for travel 7.4%, loyalty marketing services 6.4%, cargo 1.5% and other revenue 1.2%, and no customer is named as a concentration.
Sources and detail on the American Airlines page3 · What it keeps from $100
Of every $100 that came in during FY2025, American kept $0.2 as net income after $3.1 of interest expense, while operating income was $2.7 per $100 of revenue.
Sources and detail on the American Airlines page4 · Where the operating profit comes from
American reports one operating segment and no profit for AAdvantage or any region, and its operating income per $100 of revenue fell from $5.7 in FY2023 to $2.7 in FY2025.
Sources and detail on the American Airlines page5 · The one thing to watch
American's fuel cost was $4,635 million in Q3 FY2026, up from $2,767 million a year earlier, and its operating income was $115 million, down from $151 million.
Sources and detail on the American Airlines page
United
1 · What it sells
United sells airline seats, plus MileagePlus miles to partners such as Chase and space for cargo, with FY2025 revenue of $59.1 billion.
Sources and detail on the United page2 · Who pays it
In FY2025, passenger tickets were 90.5% of United's revenue, other revenue, mostly MileagePlus partners, 6.5% and cargo 3.0%, and the split by customer is not disclosed.
Sources and detail on the United page3 · What it keeps from $100
Of every $100 that came in during FY2025, United kept $5.6 as net income, which includes $611 million of interest income, while operating income was $8.0 per $100 of revenue.
Sources and detail on the United page4 · Where the operating profit comes from
United reports one airline segment and no profit by route, hub or loyalty program, so its FY2025 operating income of $4,713 million has no breakdown.
Sources and detail on the United page5 · The one thing to watch
United's fuel cost was $4,843 million in Q3 FY2026, up from $2,997 million a year earlier, while its revenue rose to $17.9 billion from $15.2 billion.
Sources and detail on the United page
Where each $100 went
Each company's own receipt for its latest full fiscal year, with matching lines in the same order where both have them.
American Airlines
Where $100 went · FY2025
| Aircraft rent | $2.2 |
|---|---|
| Salaries, wages and benefits | $31.9 |
| Aircraft fuel and related taxes | $19.5 |
| Other operating costs | $12.4 |
| Regional airline expenses | $9.9 |
| Maintenance, materials and repairs | $7.0 |
| Other rent and landing fees | $6.3 |
| Selling expenses | $3.6 |
| Depreciation and amortization (mainline) | $3.4 |
| Interest expense | $3.1 |
| Special items | $0.3 |
| Income tax | $0.1 |
| Kept as net income | $0.2 |
| Total | $100 |
Cityfort calculation from the FY2025 10-K. Of every $100 that came in during FY2025: each line = line ÷ $55,072 million × 100 (revenue $54,633 million + interest income $357 million + other income $82 million). Rounded lines add to $99.9. Per $100 of revenue alone, operating income was $2.7 and net income $0.2.
United
Where $100 went · FY2025
| Aircraft rent | $0.4 |
|---|---|
| Salaries and related | $29.5 |
| Aircraft fuel | $19.1 |
| Other operating costs (ground handling, food, navigation fees, IT) | $16.6 |
| Landing fees and other rent | $6.4 |
| Aircraft maintenance | $5.5 |
| Depreciation and amortization | $4.9 |
| Regional partners (United Express) | $4.5 |
| Distribution (card fees, commissions, booking fees) | $3.5 |
| Interest, after capitalized interest | $2.0 |
| Special charges | $0.4 |
| Income tax | $1.6 |
| Kept as net income | $5.6 |
| Total | $100 |
Cityfort calculation from the FY2025 10-K. Of every $100 that came in during FY2025: each line = line ÷ $59,829 million × 100 (revenue $59,070 million + interest income and other gains $759 million). Lines are rounded so they total $100.0; fuel is $19.05 before rounding. Per $100 of revenue alone, net income was $5.7 and operating income $8.0.
Line items differ because each company groups its costs its own way in its filings. Only on American Airlines' receipt: Salaries, wages and benefits; Aircraft fuel and related taxes; Other operating costs; Regional airline expenses; Maintenance, materials and repairs; Other rent and landing fees; Selling expenses; Depreciation and amortization (mainline); Interest expense; Special items. Only on United's receipt: Salaries and related; Aircraft fuel; Other operating costs (ground handling, food, navigation fees, IT); Landing fees and other rent; Aircraft maintenance; Depreciation and amortization; Regional partners (United Express); Distribution (card fees, commissions, booking fees); Interest, after capitalized interest; Special charges.
Revenue, net income and free cash flow
Up to five fiscal years for each company, drawn on one shared scale per measure. Amounts in US$ as reported (GAAP).
Revenue
American Airlines
United
See the numbers
Net income
American Airlines
United
See the numbers
Free cash flow
American Airlines
United
See the numbers
Growth and net margin, FY2021 to FY2025
Worked out over the years both pages cover, so the two growth figures use the same span. Net margin is net income as a share of revenue, as on each page.
American Airlines
- Revenue, per year
- +16.3%
- Net income, per year
- –
Profit growth is not worked out when either year is a loss or zero.
United
- Revenue, per year
- +24.4%
- Net income, per year
- –
Profit growth is not worked out when either year is a loss or zero.
Cityfort calculation: compound growth per year from FY2021 to FY2025 (4 years), from each page's yearly numbers, as reported.
Net margin by year
Latest quarter, against the same quarter a year earlier
Each page's latest quarter as reported; the change is a Cityfort calculation.
American Airlines
Q3 FY2026, the quarter to Sep 30, 2026, against Q3 FY2025
| Measure | Q3 FY2026 | Q3 FY2025 | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Revenue | $16.3B | $13.7B | +19.3% |
| Net income | −$269M | −$114M | – |
United
Q3 FY2026, the quarter to Sep 30, 2026, against Q3 FY2025
| Measure | Q3 FY2026 | Q3 FY2025 | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Revenue | $17.9B | $15.2B | +17.4% |
| Net income | $1.0B | $949M | +8.4% |
Sources: American Airlines S15, S14, S13, S12, S11 · United S7, S11, S10, S9, S8
Who pays each company
American Airlines
- Travelers buying tickets · 83.5% of revenue83.5% of FY2025 revenue, or $45,607 million of passenger travel.
- AAdvantage members redeeming miles · 7.4% of revenue7.4% of FY2025 revenue, or $4,036 million. Members earn miles by flying and by spending with partners.
- Citi and other loyalty partners · 6.4% of revenue6.4% of FY2025 revenue, or $3,511 million of loyalty marketing services. Citi is the most significant mileage partner.
- Cargo shippers · 1.5% of revenue1.5% of FY2025 revenue, or $839 million.
- Other · 1.2% of revenue1.2% of FY2025 revenue, or $640 million.
United
- Travelers · 90.5% of revenue90.5% of FY2025 revenue, or $53,438 million, including $4.8 billion of extra fees. 181.1 million passengers flew in 2025.
- MileagePlus partners and other services · 6.5% of revenue6.5% of FY2025 revenue, or $3,853 million. It includes $3.2 billion paid under partner agreements, such as the Chase card deal.
- Cargo shippers · 3.0% of revenue3.0% of FY2025 revenue, or $1,779 million.
Revenue by segment
American Airlines
FY2025
| Segment | Revenue | Share |
|---|---|---|
| American Airlines (one reported segment) | $54.6B | 100.0% |
United
Not on the United page.
Sources: American Airlines S1
Where the revenue comes from
Revenue by region, as each company splits it, with the period.
American Airlines
FY2025
- Domestic (share of passenger revenue)70.9%
- Atlantic13.3%
- Latin America13.0%
- Pacific2.9%
United
FY2025
- Domestic (U.S. and Canada)59.3%
- Atlantic19.7%
- Pacific11.6%
- Latin America9.4%
Debt and cash
American Airlines
- Debt
- $29.6B
- Cash and investments
- $8.3B
On Sep 30, 2026.
On Sep 30, 2026, American had $29.6 billion of debt and finance leases, $8.3 billion of cash and short-term investments, and a stockholders' deficit of $4.2 billion.
United
- Debt
- $26.4B
- Cash and investments
- $14.7B
On Sep 30, 2026.
On Sep 30, 2026, United had $26.4 billion of debt, finance leases and other financial liabilities and $14.7 billion of cash and short-term investments, against $25.0 billion and $12.2 billion on Dec 31, 2025.
Who owns each company
American Airlines
- One class of shares.
- Officers and directors as a group: 0.7% of shares (as of Apr 13, 2026).
- PRIMECAP Management Company: 10.5% (as of Jun 5, 2026).
- BlackRock, Inc.: 9.4% (as of Oct 27, 2026).
- Vanguard Capital Management: 5.1% (as of Apr 29, 2026).
United
- 3 classes of shares (votes per share: Common stock 1, Class Pilot MEC Junior Preferred Stock 1, Class IAM Junior Preferred Stock 1).
- Officers and directors as a group: 0.9% of shares (as of Mar 24, 2026).
- Vanguard Capital Management: 7.3% (as of Apr 30, 2026).
- BlackRock, Inc.: 6.6% (as of Apr 7, 2026).
- FMR LLC: 5.1% (as of Apr 7, 2026).
Sources: American Airlines S20, S5, S21, S22, S23, S24 · United S19, S4, S21, S20, S23, S22
What protects each business
What each page lists as protecting the business from competitors, each with its written reason. These describe business traits, not the share.
American Airlines
- Hub network
Nine US hubs feed over 350 destinations, and American boarded about 224 million passengers in 2025.
- AAdvantage and the Citi card
Co-brand card and other partners paid $6.2 billion in cash in 2025. Loyalty lines were 13.8% of FY2025 revenue (Cityfort calculation from the FY2025 10-K).
- International partners
A founding member of oneworld, with joint businesses with British Airways, Japan Airlines and Qantas. Atlantic and Pacific flights were 16.1% of FY2025 passenger revenue (Cityfort calculation from the FY2025 10-K).
United
- Hub network
Eight hubs, including Chicago, Denver, Newark and San Francisco, fed 330,284 million seat miles in FY2025. United's 10-K calls it the world's largest airline by available seat miles.
- Loyalty and card partners
Partner payments in other revenue rose from $2.7 billion in FY2023 to $3.2 billion in FY2025. Chase is the most significant contract for miles.
- Airline alliances
Star Alliance membership and joint businesses with Air Canada, Lufthansa Group and ANA connect United's network to theirs.
Where growth could come from
Each page's growth drivers. The status compares progress with what the company itself said it would do; it is not a view on the share.
American Airlines
- Premium cabins · Working: on track against what the company saidPremium revenue up 22.9%, Q3 FY2026
- AAdvantage and the Citi card · Working: on track against what the company said$3,511M loyalty marketing revenue, FY2025
- Corporate travel · Working: on track against what the company saidManaged corporate revenue up 27.6%, Q3 FY2026
- Passing fuel costs into fares · Mixed: partly on trackRevenue $16,335M, Q3 FY2026
- Paying down debt · Mixed: partly on track$36,366M company total debt, Sep 30, 2026
United
- Passing fuel costs into fares · Mixed: partly on track20.19 cents revenue per seat mile, Q3 FY2026
- Premium cabins and loyalty · Working: on track against what the company said+17% premium revenue, Q3 FY2026
- MileagePlus partner payments · Working: on track against what the company said$3.2B, FY2025
- United Next fleet plan · Mixed: partly on track552 aircraft on firm order, Sep 30, 2026
- Credit ratings · Working: on track against what the company saidBB+ / Ba1 / BB+, Oct 21, 2026
Sources: American Airlines S11, S19, S1, S15, S13, S14 · United S7, S1, S4, S9
Dividends, buybacks, auditor and credit rating
Dividends per share and buybacks for up to five years, the independent auditor and the latest credit rating, as each page records them.
American Airlines
- Dividends per shareNo dividends on the page up to FY2025.
- BuybacksNone on the page in the last five years.
- AuditorKPMG LLP, since 2014
- Credit ratingNot checked for this page.
United
- Dividends per shareFY2021: $0.00 · FY2022: $0.00 · FY2023: $0.00 · FY2024: $0.00 · FY2025: $0.00
- Buybacks
- Dec 31, 2024: FY2024: paid $162 million for its own shares, under a $1.5 billion program announced on Oct 15, 2024. ($162M)
- Dec 31, 2025: FY2025: about 8.1 million shares at an average of $78.75; the cash flow statement shows $637 million. ($637M)
- Sep 30, 2026: First nine months of FY2026: about 0.3 million shares for $27 million, none in Q3. $755 million of the program was left at Oct 15, 2026. ($27M)
- AuditorErnst & Young LLP, since 2009
- Credit ratingS&P, Moody's and Fitch: BB+, Ba1 and BB+, outlook Positive at S&P (since January 2026), stable at Moody's, positive at Fitch (since July 2026) (Oct 21, 2026)
Risks only one page tracks
Risks whose type the other company's page does not list. Both pages track risks of these types: commodity costs, debt, execution, legal cases. Every risk is on each company's page.
American Airlines
- Events outside its control (other)The FY2025 10-K names government shutdowns as a risk. The Q4 FY2025 shutdown cut revenue by about $325 million, and winter storms cut Q1 FY2026 revenue by about $320 million.
- Competition on fares (competition)The FY2025 10-K calls the industry intensely competitive and names nine US rivals. FY2025 passenger revenue was $49,643 million, against $49,586 million in FY2024, while capacity, in available seat miles, rose 2.2%, as stated in the FY2025 10-K.
- Card processing agreements (liquidity)American's FY2025 10-K says its credit card processing agreements could affect its liquidity if its finances worsen. Total available liquidity was $11.8 billion on Sep 30, 2026, by the company.
United
- Changes to MileagePlus or card rules (customer or supplier concentration)Chase is United's most significant contract to sell miles. United's FY2025 10-K names changes to the program, its partners or laws on credit card benefits as risks.
- Conflict and travel demand (demand)United's Q1 FY2026 10-Q says Middle East tensions disrupted flying in the region. In Q3 FY2026, Middle East, India and Africa passenger revenue fell 17.3%, on 36.5% less capacity.
- Gains inside reported profit (other)Special credits in the first nine months of FY2026 included about $1.1 billion of gains on aircraft sale-leasebacks. Q3 FY2026 GAAP diluted EPS was $3.14; adjusted EPS, without them, was $2.54.
Sources: American Airlines S1, S14, S13, S11, S5 · United S1, S5, S7, S4
Key facts
- How does American Airlines make money compared with United?
- American Airlines' revenue by payer: Travelers buying tickets 83.5%, AAdvantage members redeeming miles 7.4%, Citi and other loyalty partners 6.4%, Cargo shippers 1.5%, Other 1.2%. United's revenue by payer: Travelers 90.5%, MileagePlus partners and other services 6.5%, Cargo shippers 3.0%.
- Which is bigger by revenue, American Airlines or United?
- American Airlines reported $54.6B of revenue in FY2025, and United reported $59.1B in FY2025.
- How much net income did American Airlines and United report?
- American Airlines reported net income of $111M in FY2025, and United reported $3.4B in FY2025.
- How much of every $100 did American Airlines and United keep as net income?
- American Airlines kept $0.2 of every $100 that came in during FY2025, and United kept $5.6 in FY2025 (Cityfort calculation from each company's annual report).
- How much debt and cash do American Airlines and United have?
- American Airlines had $29.6B of debt and $8.3B of cash and investments on Sep 30, 2026. United had $26.4B of debt and $14.7B of cash and investments on Sep 30, 2026.
- When do American Airlines' and United's fiscal years end?
- American Airlines: Fiscal year ends Dec 31. United: Fiscal year ends Dec 31.
Sources: American Airlines S4, S3, S1, S11, S5 · United S2, S1, S7, S4
Built from each company's page. American Airlines updated Nov 6, 2026; United updated Nov 6, 2026.
Sources
American Airlines
- S1Form 10-K, fiscal year 2025 (ended Dec 31, 2025), American Airlines Group Inc. (SEC EDGAR), Feb 18, 2026
- S3Form 10-K, fiscal year 2023 (ended Dec 31, 2023), American Airlines Group Inc. (SEC EDGAR), Feb 21, 2024
- S4Form 10-K, fiscal year 2022 (ended Dec 31, 2022), American Airlines Group Inc. (SEC EDGAR), Feb 22, 2023
- S5Form 10-Q, Q3 FY2026 (quarter ended Sep 30, 2026), American Airlines Group Inc. (SEC EDGAR), Oct 22, 2026
- S11Earnings release, Q3 FY2026 (Form 8-K Exhibit 99.1, Oct 22, 2026), American Airlines Group Inc. (SEC EDGAR), Oct 22, 2026
- S12Earnings release, Q2 FY2026 (Form 8-K Exhibit 99.1, Jul 23, 2026), American Airlines Group Inc. (SEC EDGAR), Jul 23, 2026
- S13Earnings release, Q1 FY2026 (Form 8-K Exhibit 99.1, Apr 23, 2026), American Airlines Group Inc. (SEC EDGAR), Apr 23, 2026
- S14Earnings release, Q4 and full year FY2025 (Form 8-K Exhibit 99.1, Jan 27, 2026), American Airlines Group Inc. (SEC EDGAR), Jan 27, 2026
- S15Earnings release, Q3 FY2025 (Form 8-K Exhibit 99.1, Oct 23, 2025), American Airlines Group Inc. (SEC EDGAR), Oct 23, 2025
- S19Third-quarter 2026 financial results presentation (Form 8-K Exhibit 99.2, Oct 22, 2026), American Airlines Group Inc. (SEC EDGAR), Oct 22, 2026
- S202026 proxy statement (DEF 14A), American Airlines Group Inc. (SEC EDGAR), Apr 28, 2026
- S21Schedule 13G/A by PRIMECAP Management Company (event May 31, 2026), PRIMECAP Management Company (SEC EDGAR), Jun 5, 2026
- S22Schedule 13G/A by BlackRock, Inc. (event Sep 30, 2026), BlackRock, Inc. (SEC EDGAR), Oct 27, 2026
- S23Schedule 13G by Vanguard Capital Management LLC (event Mar 31, 2026), Vanguard Capital Management LLC (SEC EDGAR), Apr 29, 2026
- S24Schedule 13G/A by The Vanguard Group (event Mar 13, 2026; 0 shares after realignment), The Vanguard Group (SEC EDGAR), Mar 26, 2026
- S28Form 8-K, Exhibit 99.1: statement on a possible United Airlines merger (Apr 17, 2026; filed Apr 20), American Airlines Group Inc. (SEC EDGAR), Apr 20, 2026
United
- S1Form 10-K, fiscal year 2025 (ended Dec 31, 2025), United Airlines Holdings, Inc. (SEC EDGAR), Feb 12, 2026
- S2Form 10-K, fiscal year 2023 (ended Dec 31, 2023), United Airlines Holdings, Inc. (SEC EDGAR), Feb 29, 2024
- S4Form 10-Q, Q3 FY2026 (quarter ended Sep 30, 2026), United Airlines Holdings, Inc. (SEC EDGAR), Oct 21, 2026
- S5Form 10-Q, Q1 FY2026 (quarter ended Mar 31, 2026), United Airlines Holdings, Inc. (SEC EDGAR), Apr 22, 2026
- S7Earnings release, third quarter 2026 (8-K Ex. 99.1), United Airlines Holdings, Inc. (SEC EDGAR), Oct 20, 2026
- S8Earnings release, second quarter 2026 (8-K Ex. 99.1), United Airlines Holdings, Inc. (SEC EDGAR), Jul 15, 2026
- S9Earnings release, first quarter 2026 (8-K Ex. 99.1), United Airlines Holdings, Inc. (SEC EDGAR), Apr 21, 2026
- S10Earnings release, fourth quarter and full year 2025 (8-K Ex. 99.1), United Airlines Holdings, Inc. (SEC EDGAR), Jan 20, 2026
- S11Earnings release, third quarter 2025 (8-K Ex. 99.1), United Airlines Holdings, Inc. (SEC EDGAR), Oct 15, 2025
- S19Proxy statement (DEF 14A), 2026 annual meeting, United Airlines Holdings, Inc. (SEC EDGAR), Apr 7, 2026
- S20Schedule 13G, Vanguard Capital Management (event Mar 31, 2026), Vanguard Capital Management (SEC EDGAR), Apr 30, 2026
- S21Schedule 13G/A, Capital International Investors (event Mar 31, 2026), Capital International Investors (SEC EDGAR), May 14, 2026
- S22Schedule 13G, FMR LLC and Abigail P. Johnson (event Dec 31, 2025), FMR LLC (SEC EDGAR), Feb 5, 2026
- S23Schedule 13G/A, The Vanguard Group (event Mar 13, 2026), The Vanguard Group (SEC EDGAR), Mar 27, 2026
- S29Delta Air Lines Form 10-K, fiscal year 2025 (ended Dec 31, 2025), competition section, Delta Air Lines, Inc. (SEC EDGAR), Feb 11, 2026
Disclaimer
For learning only. Cityfort is not a registered investment adviser or broker-dealer and does not recommend buying or selling any security. Prices shown are dated and may be out of date.
Investing in securities involves risk, including loss of capital. Before making any investment decision, do your own research and consider consulting a registered investment adviser or other qualified professional.
Cityfort, its owners and contributors may or may not hold securities of companies covered. Cityfort is not paid by any company it covers. Content is not an offer or solicitation to buy or sell any security, including in any initial public offering.
Read the positions policyRead the full disclaimerHide the full disclaimer
Cityfort publishes general educational content that explains how listed companies work. Cityfort is not registered with the US Securities and Exchange Commission or any state securities regulator as an investment adviser, and is not a broker-dealer or a member of FINRA. Cityfort does not provide investment, tax or legal advice, recommendations, ratings, price targets or any opinion on whether to buy, sell or hold any security. Nothing on the site is tailored to any person's circumstances.
All information is taken from publicly available sources, mainly company filings with the SEC, which are listed on each page with dates. We work to keep it accurate and correct errors publicly, but we do not guarantee that it is complete, accurate or up to date. Any market price or price-based ratio shown is dated, may be out of date by the time you read it, and is included only to explain concepts.
Statements by company management, including forward-looking statements and guidance, are reported as the company's statements, with their date and source; they are not our forecasts. Adjusted (non-GAAP) figures are the company's own measures and are shown next to the official (GAAP) figures.